Kingston Council Weighs AI Plan Review Software
- •Kingston officials considered $54,700 in startup costs for AI plan review software targeted for early 2027.
- •Council members raised privacy, data ownership, accuracy and testing concerns; staff would review the software’s reports.
- •The department aims for fully digital permits by July 2027 and has reviewed around 600 units over four years.
Kingston, N.Y., Building Safety and Zoning Enforcement Director Steve Knox asked the Common Council to approve $54,700 in startup costs for AI plan review software, with implementation targeted for early 2027. The proposal came before the council’s Finance and Audit Committee as it reviewed the Building Department’s $2,046,724 request in Mayor Steve Noble’s proposed $69.4 million budget. The software would connect to the department’s existing City Squared online application review system and require a yearly subscription, with additional annual costs.
Knox said the software could produce in hours reports that currently take three to four days. Council members questioned how the vendor would collect, retain and own public and personal data, and raised concerns about AI errors and whether the product had been adequately tested. Council President Andrea Shaut said she could see value if privacy protections were assured, while Michael Tierney sought more information about the company’s data policies. Teryl Mickens asked whether the system would affect staffing and review time; Knox said three department employees handle most reviews and he did not expect staff reductions. Reports would still be reviewed by staff.
Knox said the department had considered several vendors but had not tested the selected software, which he called the best fit. He agreed to contact similar municipalities about their experience. The department removed a code enforcement director role from its proposed 2027 budget; Knox said the software would help address the need for that position, alongside transferring some code violation work to the Corporation Counsel’s office. A historic preservation professional also described online applications that remain partly handwritten and can appear stuck under review while staff wait for more information.
Knox said Kingston hopes to make the permitting process fully digital by July 2027. He said the AI system could email applicants for missing documents and answer general questions, and the department has reviewed around 600 units over the past four years. The proposal follows other local disputes over government AI: on October 22, the Ulster County Sheriff’s Office said it would end a trial of AI-assisted report writing and drop plans for additional Motorola automatic license plate reader cameras. County Executive Jen Metzger signed an order that day banning AI surveillance technologies in her administration; the sheriff supported the order.
The fastest, most reliable AI news, straight to your inbox